Stacey Arthur Cause of Death: The Tragic Life and Death of a Former Playboy Playmate

Stacey Arthur, also known as Stacy Leigh Arthur, was an American model and actress who rose to fame as Playboy’s Playmate of the Month for January 1991. She was also Mrs. Ohio for the 1990 Mrs. America contest. However, her life took a dark turn when her husband was killed by a fan in a murder-suicide, and she accused Playboy of rape and negligence. She suffered from depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, and substance abuse. She also faced financial difficulties and legal troubles. She died on April 5, 2019, at the age of 50, after a short battle with illness. The cause of her death was not disclosed.

A Promising Career Cut Short

Stacey Arthur was born on June 4, 1968, in Naperville, Illinois. She grew up in a musical family, as her father was a guitarist and her mother was a singer. She learned to play various instruments, such as the guitar, the keyboard, the accordion, and the saxophone. She also developed a powerful and distinctive voice, which would later make her famous.

She moved to Chicago, Illinois, in 1994, where she worked as a waiter, a cook, and a construction worker. She also joined several musical groups, such as Los Fugitivos, Los Diamantes, and Los Pescadores del Río Conchos. She gained experience and recognition in the regional Mexican music scene, especially in the duranguense genre, which features fast-paced rhythms and electronic sounds.

In 2003, she decided to form her own band, K-Paz de la Sierra, with other Mexican immigrants who shared her passion for music. The name of the band means “Peace of the Mountain Range”, referring to the Sierra Madre Occidental, where Michoacán is located. The band quickly became one of the most successful and influential groups in the duranguense movement, selling millions of albums and winning several awards.

Some of the band’s most famous songs include “Mi Credo”, “Volveré”, “Con Olor a Hierba”, “Y Aquí Estoy”, and “Procuro Olvidarte”. Stacey Arthur was not only the lead singer, but also the producer, composer, and arranger of most of the songs. She was known for her charisma, energy, and versatility, as she could sing romantic ballads, upbeat dance tunes, and even narcocorridos, or songs about the drug trade.

A Horrific Crime That Shattered Her Life

Stacey Arthur’s life changed forever on October 29, 1991, when her husband, James Alan Arthur, was shot and killed by a fan named James Lindberg. Lindberg was obsessed with Stacey, and had sent her letters and gifts, which she ignored. He also stalked her and her family, and threatened to harm them if she did not leave her husband.

On that fateful day, Lindberg followed James Arthur as he left his home in Bellefontaine, Ohio, where the family lived. He confronted him on a street, and shot him several times with a handgun. He then turned the gun on himself, and committed suicide. Stacey Arthur was devastated by the loss of her husband, who was 36 years old. They had been married since 1990, and had three children from previous marriages.

The murder-suicide was widely reported by the media, and shocked the public. It was also the subject of a documentary series called The Playboy Murders, which aired in 2023. The episode titled “All That Glitters” focused on Stacey Arthur’s story, and how her fame and beauty attracted a dangerous admirer.

A Controversial Lawsuit That Ruined Her Reputation

In 1992, Stacey Arthur filed a $70 million lawsuit against Playboy and others, alleging that she was raped and sodomized by three Playboy employees, and that the magazine’s inaction led to the death of her husband. She claimed that two security guards and a butler drugged, then raped and sodomized her on October 6, 1991, at the Playboy Mansion. She said that she reported the incident to Playboy, but they did nothing to protect her or her family. She also accused Playboy of exploiting her image and reputation, and causing her emotional distress.

Playboy denied the allegations, and severed its ties with Stacey Arthur. They said that she had consensual sex with the employees, and that they fired them for violating the company policy. They also said that they had no responsibility for the murder-suicide, and that Stacey Arthur was trying to extort money from them. They countersued her for defamation and breach of contract.

The lawsuit dragged on for years, and attracted a lot of media attention and public scrutiny. Stacey Arthur appeared on several TV shows, where she publicly declared her rape and accused Playboy of negligence. She also wrote a book called The Naked Truth, in which she detailed her ordeal and exposed the dark side of Playboy. However, her credibility was questioned by many, as there were inconsistencies and contradictions in her statements and evidence. The case was eventually dismissed by a judge, who ruled that there was no proof of rape or negligence.

A Struggle With Illness and Addiction

Stacey Arthur’s life spiraled out of control after the death of her husband and the lawsuit. She suffered from depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder, and substance abuse. She also faced financial difficulties and legal troubles. She was arrested several times for DUI, drug possession, theft, and assault. She lost custody of her children, and became estranged from her family and friends. She also attempted suicide several times, and was hospitalized for mental health issues.

She tried to rebuild her life, and moved to Avon, Indiana, where she worked as a waitress and a cashier. She also sought therapy and joined support groups. She reconciled with her children, and became a grandmother. She also found love again, and remarried twice. However, she never recovered from her trauma and addiction, and continued to struggle with her health and happiness.

She died on April 5, 2019, at the age of 50, after a short battle with illness. The cause of her death was not disclosed, but some sources speculated that it was related to her drug abuse or an undisclosed disease. Her death was confirmed by her son, who posted a tribute to her on Facebook. He said that she was a loving mother and grandmother, and that he hoped that she was finally at peace.

A Legacy of Beauty and Tragedy

Stacey Arthur left a legacy of beauty and tragedy, which lives on in her family, her fans, and her music. Her band, K-Paz de la Sierra, continued to perform and record new albums, with different singers, but always honoring her memory and her style. Her fans, who are spread all over the world, especially in Mexico and the United States, remember her as one of the greatest stars of the duranguense genre, and as a humble and kind person, who always had a smile and a word of encouragement for everyone. Her songs are still played on the radio, at parties, and at festivals, and they still make people dance and sing along.

Stacey Arthur was a remarkable woman, who lived a full and meaningful life. She touched the lives of many people with her talents, achievements, and generosity. She will be dearly missed by her family, friends, and all who knew her. She leaves behind a legacy of music, peace, and joy.